Tue. May 28th, 2024

A gruesome botched execution saw a Death Row killer’s head burst into flames in 1997.

Pedro Medina, a Cuban refugee, then 39, murdered his neighbor 52-year-old Dorothy James in Orlando, Florida, on April 4, 1982.

He was due to be electrocuted to death by the infamous electric chair, Old Sparky, in Florida State Prison on March 25, 1997. early 15 years after the crime.

But the chair malfunctioned, causing foot-long flames to shoot out of his head. It burst from behind the mask over his face, filling the death chamber with smoke.

Executions in Florida were delayed by almost a whole year due to this incident.

Medina, who just prior to his arrival in the US had been released from a Cuban mental hospital, was sentenced to death for murdering former teacher. She was found gagged, stabbed multiple times with a knife, and left to die in her Orlando home.

Similar: 4 Years After an Execution a Different Man’s DNA is Found on the Murder Weapon

He was found on April 8, 1982, asleep in her car, which he had stolen, at a rest stop near Lake City, and was initially arrested for theft.

Detective Daniel Nazerchuk indicted him of the murder on a day later.

Medina was evaluated by two psychiatrists upon his request – but they confirmed that he was competent enough to stand trial before a jury between March 15-18, 1983.

He was convicted of first degree murder and auto theft, serving five years in prison for the theft and was recommended the death penalty for the murder.

Within seconds of the electric current being applied, smoke appeared from under the right side of the head piece. The current was not shut off until the middle of its third cycle. The flames lasted between four to five seconds.

The body was left with a third degree burn ring on the crown of the head. It’s a common occurrence by judicial electrocutions. His eyebrows, eyelashes, and facial hair did not burn away. But, his face and head were charred and scalded by the steam.

Patricia McCusker, Superintendent of Work Camp at Florida State Prison, testified in court that she witnessed this malfunction.

Similar: Texas Man Faces Lethal Injection for Fatal Beating of 83-year-old Great Aunt Who Refused to Let Him Borrow Money

She said, “Medina’s left hand tightened as the current was applied, and there was a burning smell, and smoke and flames came from his head. I saw movements in his chest, but the contractions did not imply he was breathing.”

Other witnesses to his death described the odour like a burnt sponge. Others had described it as the smell of burning flesh.

His chest muscles contracted with lurching, spasmodic movements as if he were shuddering, two or three times within four minutes. The witnesses to his death did not believe that he was breathing at this moment.

Medina was pronounced dead at 7:10am. In his last words, he claimed, “I am still innocent.”

This gory incident caught the attention of objectors to the death penalty, who questioned whether Medina really was mentally competent to stand trial in the first place.

Lorry Post, an anti-death penalty activist from New Jersey, US, said, “The horror becomes more of a horror.

“Even before his execution, people, including Pope John Paul II, spoke out against the killing of Medina, a mentally ill Cuban refugee.”

The victim’s daughter, Lindi James, even stated that despite her belief that Medina was innocent, her mother would have opposed the execution regardless.

Attorney General Bob Butterworth insisted that, “Old Sparky does its job fine. [Although] People who wish to commit murder, better not do it in the state of Florida because we may have a problem with our electric chair.”

Follow Illicit Deeds on Facebook for more stories.

Support Independent Journalism and help us continue covering the stories that matter to you.


Tell us your thoughts...

By Buffy Gunner

Independent Journalist + Business Owner | Lover of all things true crime. Mantra: Only YOU can be YOU. | Los Angeles Born | buffygunner@illicitdeeds.com